Kristi Scott
Conversation Date: September 24th, 2024 12pm CST
Listen:
Watch:
Read Overview:
Unlocking the Power of Email Fundraising: Donor Welcome Sequences That Work
In today’s digital age, email marketing remains a cornerstone for nonprofit fundraising, yet many organizations overlook its potential. On the Million Dollar Nonprofit Podcast, Tom Kelly sat down with Kristi Scott, a nonprofit email fundraising consultant, to explore how donor welcome sequences can transform one-time donors into lifelong supporters. With over a decade of experience in nonprofit programs, fundraising, and marketing, Kristi shared actionable insights and strategies to maximize email campaigns.
Why Email Isn’t Dead
One common misconception is that email marketing is outdated or unwanted. Kristi addressed this myth head-on, emphasizing that donors passionate about your mission want to hear from you. While unsubscribes might happen, it’s better to focus on those who stay engaged. She encouraged nonprofits to send frequent, value-packed emails and offer supporters the option to adjust their email preferences to avoid feeling overwhelmed.
The Role of a Donor Welcome Sequence
When a donor makes their first gift, they’re often at their highest level of engagement. A well-designed welcome sequence capitalizes on this moment by:
1. Introducing Your Mission and Vision
Many donors may only know a small part of your story. The welcome sequence provides an opportunity to share your nonprofit’s broader mission, values, and impact.
2. Building Relationships Through Stories
By highlighting success stories and showcasing how donor contributions make a difference, you create an emotional connection that deepens their commitment.
3. Setting Expectations for Future Communication
The sequence informs donors about the type and frequency of emails they’ll receive, fostering trust and transparency.
Key Components of a Successful Welcome Sequence
Kristi broke down the essentials of crafting an effective donor welcome sequence:
- Keep It Simple: Use clear, concise language and repurpose existing content like success stories or mission statements.
- Plan Ahead: Collaborate with staff across departments to align messaging and gather impactful stories.
- Test and Refine: Always test your emails for personalization (e.g., using first names correctly) and track metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and unsubscribe rates.
- Engage Beyond Donations: Invite donors to participate in events, volunteer opportunities, or social media sharing.
How Many Emails Are Ideal?
Kristi recommended a minimum of three emails for a welcome sequence, with a maximum of seven. Each email should serve a distinct purpose, such as:
1. Thank You Email
Express gratitude and acknowledge the donor’s gift.
2. Mission Introduction
Share your nonprofit’s mission, vision, and a success story.
3. Engagement Opportunity
Highlight ways the donor can get involved beyond giving, such as volunteering or attending events.
Avoiding Common Mistakes
Kristi shared several pitfalls nonprofits should avoid when launching their first donor welcome sequence:
1. Neglecting Personalization
Ensure email tags like first names are correctly set up to avoid awkward errors (e.g., “Dear [First Name]”).
2. Overwhelming with Information
Focus on key messages rather than bombarding donors with too much detail.
3. Failing to Test
Always send test emails to ensure formatting, links, and personalization work as intended.
Engaging Existing Donors
For organizations that lack a welcome sequence or want to reengage existing donors, Kristi suggested repurposing the sequence for reintroductions. Tailor the messaging to acknowledge their past support and provide updates on your organization’s progress.
Measuring Success
The primary goals of a welcome sequence are donor engagement and retention. Key metrics to track include:
- Open Rates: The percentage of recipients who open your emails.
- Click-Through Rates: The percentage who interact with links in your emails.
- Unsubscribe Rates: Monitor spikes in unsubscribes to identify potential issues with your content.
Kristi’s Free Email Templates
To help nonprofits get started, Kristi offers a free three-part welcome sequence template. Designed for small nonprofits, the template provides a foundation for crafting impactful emails while saving time and effort. It’s perfect for new donors but can also be adapted for other segments of your email list.
Top 5 Takeaways
1. Frequent Emails Are Okay
Donors committed to your mission won’t mind receiving regular updates.
2. Keep It Simple
Repurpose existing content and focus on clear messaging.
3. Three Emails Minimum
A welcome sequence should have at least three emails to engage new donors effectively.
4. Engage Existing Donors
Reintroduce your mission to past donors using a refreshed version of the welcome sequence.
5. Don’t Overcomplicate
Focus on storytelling and relationship-building over perfection.
Final Thoughts
Email fundraising doesn’t have to be daunting. By implementing a donor welcome sequence, nonprofits can create lasting relationships that go beyond the first donation. Kristi’s practical tips and free resources make it easy for organizations of any size to get started.
Ready to unlock the power of email fundraising? Download Kristi’s free templates at kScott.link/newdonor and take your email campaigns to the next level!
Ready to unlock the power of email fundraising? Download Kristi’s free templates at kScott.link/newdonor and take your email campaigns to the next level!
Frequently
Asked Questions
A donor welcome sequence is a series of automated emails sent to new donors after they make a gift. It introduces them to your organization, shares your mission and impact, and fosters engagement beyond their initial donation.
A welcome sequence capitalizes on the donor’s initial enthusiasm by deepening their understanding of your mission, building trust, and increasing the likelihood of future support, whether through additional donations, volunteering, or advocacy.
The ideal sequence includes at least three emails but no more than seven. Start with a thank-you message, followed by emails that share your mission, success stories, and ways to engage further.
While the focus should not be on asking for additional donations, it’s okay to include a soft donate button at the bottom of the emails. The primary goal is to educate and engage, not to solicit immediately.
Use tools like merge tags for first names to personalize emails. Ensure all donor data is accurate before sending, and test your emails to avoid errors like “Dear [First Name].”
Avoid overwhelming donors with too much information, neglecting to test personalization, or reusing stale content without context. Keep your messaging simple, engaging, and focused on your organization’s impact.
Track metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and unsubscribe rates. Evaluate how the sequence influences donor retention, monthly giving sign-ups, and overall engagement with your organization.
Absolutely! A welcome sequence can be repurposed to reintroduce and reengage existing donors who may not have received one initially. Tailor the messaging to acknowledge their past support and provide updates on your mission and impact.