Sean
Conversation Date: September 12th, 2024 12pm CST
Listen:
Watch:
Read Overview:
5 Creative Metrics Every Nonprofit Should Track for Growth and Success
In today’s fast-paced nonprofit world, effectively measuring and communicating your organization’s impact is essential. Our guest, Sean Kosofsky, aka the “Nonprofit Fixer,” shares valuable insights on creative metrics every nonprofit should consider. With over 30 years of experience, Sean has crafted innovative approaches that help nonprofits build stronger reputations, improve resilience, and effectively tell their stories to funders and stakeholders.
Top 5 Creative Metrics to Boost Your Nonprofit’s Impact
While Sean has identified 18 creative metrics in total, here are his top five:
1. Leveraging Technology for Growth
Improving your technology is a measurable way to show growth and effectiveness. When nonprofits invest in better software, productivity tools, or CRMs, they increase efficiency and collaboration. Sean notes that these upgrades allow nonprofits to scale impact by making teams more productive. Today’s AI tools and platforms offer nonprofit-friendly discounts or free access, giving organizations an edge in achieving their mission faster. The goal is to show funders that your organization is growing by leveraging technology to make a bigger impact.
2. Building and Maintaining Reputation
Your reputation is your organization’s currency. Over time, fostering relationships with media, lawmakers, local businesses, and donors strengthens your network and improves credibility. A strong reputation means people return your calls, engage in your events, and rally behind your cause. Sean emphasizes that showing funders how reputation contributes to your impact can go a long way in attracting support.
3. Talent Acquisition and Retention
Attracting and retaining talented board members, staff, volunteers, and interns is a powerful indicator of your organization’s capacity. According to Sean, nonprofits should view their teams as assets. Track the skills, hours, and contributions of your people to showcase the depth and quality of your programs. Funders are often impressed when nonprofits demonstrate how they’ve assembled a strong team to execute their mission.
4. Organizational Resilience
How well can your organization withstand crises? Resilience is more than having a rainy-day fund; it’s about having protocols and policies for unexpected challenges. From crisis communication plans to emergency funds, resilience planning reassures funders that your organization can weather storms like the COVID-19 pandemic or economic downturns. Sean suggests creating a crisis management checklist to showcase your organization’s preparedness to funders.
5. Preventing Harm
Preventing negative outcomes can be as impactful as achieving positive ones. For example, Sean recalls his time at an LGBTQ civil rights organization, where their visibility deterred discriminatory legislation. Highlighting how your organization’s presence prevents harm in your community or field can be a powerful story for funders. By being there to answer calls, offer support, or act as a watchdog, your nonprofit may prevent crises before they arise.
Implementing These Metrics: Practical Tips
Many nonprofits struggle with measurement due to budget or time constraints. Sean offers a few ways to get started:
Scenario Planning for Resilience
Start with conversations to identify and mitigate potential risks. Scenario planning can be a free, simple way to bolster your organization’s resilience.
Tracking Qualitative Data
Surveys and success journals allow you to track changes in clients’ well-being before and after receiving your services, capturing data without the need for advanced evaluation tools.
Using Technology for Efficiency
Leverage tools like AI to simplify tasks. Rather than authoring from scratch, use AI for brainstorming or initial drafts.
Final Thoughts: The Importance of Storytelling
Sean underscores the importance of storytelling in fundraising and outreach. Metrics are valuable, but the real impact comes when nonprofits convey their work in a compelling way that resonates with funders. Building a community around shared goals requires nonprofits to “show, not tell.” By displaying results, positive relationships, and engagement, nonprofits can attract more supporters and build lasting partnerships.
Get the Full List of 18 Metrics
To dive deeper into Sean’s 18 creative metrics, visit his website, nonprofitfixer.com, where you’ll find tools and resources tailored for nonprofit leaders. Whether you’re new to these concepts or looking to refine your strategies, these metrics provide a framework to showcase your organization’s effectiveness and growth potential.
Sean
National Nonprofit Expert, Coach, Consultant, and Trainer. I transform nonprofit leaders and organizations. 5 x Nonprofit Executive Director
More Resources
Frequently
Asked Questions
Creative metrics allow nonprofits to measure their effectiveness beyond traditional metrics like donation amounts. They help showcase the organization’s overall health, growth, and resilience, which can be compelling for funders and stakeholders.
Track technology improvements by listing software upgrades, new tools adopted, or productivity increases resulting from technology use. You can also note any cost savings or time efficiencies gained with these tools.
Highlighting relationships with community members, media coverage, positive feedback, testimonials, and partnerships can help build and show your reputation. Collect quotes, testimonials, and press mentions to document this.
Small nonprofits can build resilience through scenario planning, establishing basic crisis policies, and creating a rainy-day fund when possible. Developing simple response plans for potential crises helps demonstrate readiness and stability.
Preventing harm involves the negative outcomes your nonprofit helps avoid by being active in the community. This could mean reducing crises, providing a safe space, or influencing policy in a positive way. Keep track of instances where your presence has deterred harmful events or encouraged positive behaviors.
Document the skills, roles, and backgrounds of new board members, staff, and volunteers, along with their contributions. Highlight how their expertise has contributed to program effectiveness or organizational growth.
Start simple by surveying clients or beneficiaries to get feedback on your services. Use basic pre- and post-service questionnaires or create a success journal where you document achievements and milestones throughout the year.
Storytelling connects metrics to real-life impact by showing the personal side of your achievements. Rather than listing numbers, share stories of how individuals or communities have benefited from your work, as these resonate more with audiences and funders.